On the Concept of Civil Legal Liability in Russian Legal Science: A Critical Analysis
Main Article Content
Abstract
This scientific article deals with the problem of the concept of civilliability. The latter is often misinterpreted by theoreticians and civilists. We believe that this is largely due to the unreasonable identification of legal liability measures and protection measures (restorative measures). The paper presents the author’s view of this problem.
Article Details
How to Cite
Kozhevnikov, V. V. (2022). On the Concept of Civil Legal Liability in Russian Legal Science: A Critical Analysis. Polit Journal Scientific Journal of Politics, 2(1), 12-18. https://doi.org/10.33258/polit.v2i1.595
Section
Articles
References
[1]. Radko Timofey Nikolaevich, Lazarev Valery Vasilyevich, Morozova Lyudmila Alexandrovna. Theory of state and law: textbook. Moscow: Prospekt, 2012.P.385.
[2]. Theory of state and law: textbook / ed. Mikhail Mikhailovich Rassolov. M.: UNITY-DANA, Law and Law, 2004.P.505.
[3]. Shagieva Rosalina Vasilievna, Sevryukov Alexander Pavlovich. Behavior of people in the legal sphere // Actual problems of the theory of state and law: study guide. / resp. ed. Rosalina Vasilievna Shagieva. Moscow: Norma, 2011. Pp. 482, 483
[4]. Braginsky Mikhail Isaakovich, Vitryansky Vasily Vladimirovich. Contract law in 3 books. Moscow: Statute, 2002. Book three. Moscow: Statute P.490.
[5]. Commentary on the Civil Code of the Russian Federation. Parts one-three / ed. Evgeny Leonidovich Zabarchuk. Moscow: Publishing house Exam, 2006. P.325.
[6]. Braginsky Mikhail Isaakovich Vitryansky V.V. Contract law. General provisions. Moscow: Statut, 1997. P.323.
[7]. Barseghyan Tariel Karapetovich. Penalty as a measure of responsibility // Lawyer. 2006. No. 7. P. 20.
[8]. Commentary on the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation / under the general editorship. Alexander Ivanovich Bastrykin. Moscow: Wolters Kluver, 2008. P.328.
[9]. Marchenko Mikhail Nikolaevich. Problems of the general theory of state and law in 2 volumes: textbook. Moscow: Prospekt, 2008. Vol. 2. Pravo.P.176.
[10]. The queen made a knight’s move//Halo. 2021. 27 Sept. -3 Oct.- P.9
[11]. Em Vladimir Saurseevich. The right to protection // Russian civil law: a textbook in 2 volumes. General part / otv. ed. Evgeny Alekseevich. Sukhanov: Statute, 2011. Vol.1. Pp.419-421.
[12]. Theory of state and law: a course of lectures / ed. Nikolai Ignatievich Matuzov and Alexander Vasilyevich Malko. Moscow: Jurist, 2001. P. 600.
[13]. Civil law: textbook / under the general editorship. Veniamin Fedorovich Yakovlev. Moscow: Publishing House of the RAGS, 2003. Pp. 426, 427, 430.
[14]. Musaeva Irina Mikhailovna Civil liability in Russian law // Issues of student science. 2020. No. 10 (50). P. 64.
[15]. Lukyantsev Alexander Anatolyevich Responsibility for violation of obligations in civil law // Civil law: a textbook in 3 parts / ed. Vladimir Pavlovich Kamyshansky and others. Moscow: Eksmo, 2010. Part one. P.650.
[16]. Khokhlova Galina Vasilievna. Coercion as a sign of civil liability Economy and law. 2003. No. 1. P. 106.
[17]. Big legal dictionary / ed. Alexander Yakovlevich Sukharev, Valery Dmitrievich Zorkin, Vladimir Emelyanovich Krutskikh. Moscow: INFRA-M., 1999. P. 463.
[18]. Gushchin Vladimir Zakharovich. Some aspects of civil liability //Modern law. 2008. No. 11. Pp. 3-8.
[19]. Vitryansky Vasily Vladimirovich. Responsibility for violation // Economy and law. 1995. No.11.P. 15.
[20]. Gongalo Bronislav Michislavovich. Responsibility for violation of obligations. Termination of obligations // Civil law: textbook. / under the general editorship. Sergei Sergeevich Alekseev. Moscow: Prospekt, 2009. Pp. 196, 198.
[21]. Fokov Anatoly Pavlovich, Poponov Yuri Gavrilovich., Cherkashina Irina Leonidovna, Cherkashin Valery Aleksandrovich. Civil law: textbook / otv. ed. Anatoly Pavlovich Fokov. Moscow: KNORUS, 2007.P.302.
[22]. Mongush Bolek Sergeevich. Functions of means of protecting civil rights//cyberleninka.ru›article…sredstv…grazhdanskih-prav (date of access: 27. 09. 21).
[23]. Eshchenko Irina Anatolyevna. Civil liability for breach of obligations // Russian judge. 2008. No.5.P. 48
[24]. Guev Alexey Nikolaevich. Civil law: a textbook in 3 volumes. Moscow: INFRA-M., 2003. Vol.1. P.7.
[25]. Egorov Nikolai Dmitrievich. Civil liability // Civil law: a textbook in 3 volumes / otv. ed. Alexander Petrovich Sergeev, Yuri Kirillovich Tolstoy. Moscow.: Prospekt, 2004. Pp. 645, 646.
[26]. Sergeev Alexander Petrovich. Protection of civil rights // Civil law: a textbook in 3 volumes./ed. Alexander Petrovich Sergeev. Moscow: Prospekt, 2012.Vol.1. Pp. 546-547.
[27]. Karkhalev Denis Nikolaevich. Correlation of measures of protection and measures of responsibility in the civil law of Russia: thesis .... cand. legal Sciences Yekaterinburg: Ur. state legal acad., 2003.P.8.
[28]. Kravchenko Alexander Alexandrovich. The ratio of protection measures and liability measures as ways to protect subjective civil rights // Russian Legal Journal. 2015. No. 2. Pp. 3-4, 5.
[29]. Andrey Alexandrovich Kondrashev. Constitutional and legal responsibility and other measures in the mechanism of protection of the constitutional system (measures of protection, control and supervision) // Scientific Yearbook of the Institute of Philosophy and Law of the Ural Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences. 2010.Issue. 10. P.399
[2]. Theory of state and law: textbook / ed. Mikhail Mikhailovich Rassolov. M.: UNITY-DANA, Law and Law, 2004.P.505.
[3]. Shagieva Rosalina Vasilievna, Sevryukov Alexander Pavlovich. Behavior of people in the legal sphere // Actual problems of the theory of state and law: study guide. / resp. ed. Rosalina Vasilievna Shagieva. Moscow: Norma, 2011. Pp. 482, 483
[4]. Braginsky Mikhail Isaakovich, Vitryansky Vasily Vladimirovich. Contract law in 3 books. Moscow: Statute, 2002. Book three. Moscow: Statute P.490.
[5]. Commentary on the Civil Code of the Russian Federation. Parts one-three / ed. Evgeny Leonidovich Zabarchuk. Moscow: Publishing house Exam, 2006. P.325.
[6]. Braginsky Mikhail Isaakovich Vitryansky V.V. Contract law. General provisions. Moscow: Statut, 1997. P.323.
[7]. Barseghyan Tariel Karapetovich. Penalty as a measure of responsibility // Lawyer. 2006. No. 7. P. 20.
[8]. Commentary on the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation / under the general editorship. Alexander Ivanovich Bastrykin. Moscow: Wolters Kluver, 2008. P.328.
[9]. Marchenko Mikhail Nikolaevich. Problems of the general theory of state and law in 2 volumes: textbook. Moscow: Prospekt, 2008. Vol. 2. Pravo.P.176.
[10]. The queen made a knight’s move//Halo. 2021. 27 Sept. -3 Oct.- P.9
[11]. Em Vladimir Saurseevich. The right to protection // Russian civil law: a textbook in 2 volumes. General part / otv. ed. Evgeny Alekseevich. Sukhanov: Statute, 2011. Vol.1. Pp.419-421.
[12]. Theory of state and law: a course of lectures / ed. Nikolai Ignatievich Matuzov and Alexander Vasilyevich Malko. Moscow: Jurist, 2001. P. 600.
[13]. Civil law: textbook / under the general editorship. Veniamin Fedorovich Yakovlev. Moscow: Publishing House of the RAGS, 2003. Pp. 426, 427, 430.
[14]. Musaeva Irina Mikhailovna Civil liability in Russian law // Issues of student science. 2020. No. 10 (50). P. 64.
[15]. Lukyantsev Alexander Anatolyevich Responsibility for violation of obligations in civil law // Civil law: a textbook in 3 parts / ed. Vladimir Pavlovich Kamyshansky and others. Moscow: Eksmo, 2010. Part one. P.650.
[16]. Khokhlova Galina Vasilievna. Coercion as a sign of civil liability Economy and law. 2003. No. 1. P. 106.
[17]. Big legal dictionary / ed. Alexander Yakovlevich Sukharev, Valery Dmitrievich Zorkin, Vladimir Emelyanovich Krutskikh. Moscow: INFRA-M., 1999. P. 463.
[18]. Gushchin Vladimir Zakharovich. Some aspects of civil liability //Modern law. 2008. No. 11. Pp. 3-8.
[19]. Vitryansky Vasily Vladimirovich. Responsibility for violation // Economy and law. 1995. No.11.P. 15.
[20]. Gongalo Bronislav Michislavovich. Responsibility for violation of obligations. Termination of obligations // Civil law: textbook. / under the general editorship. Sergei Sergeevich Alekseev. Moscow: Prospekt, 2009. Pp. 196, 198.
[21]. Fokov Anatoly Pavlovich, Poponov Yuri Gavrilovich., Cherkashina Irina Leonidovna, Cherkashin Valery Aleksandrovich. Civil law: textbook / otv. ed. Anatoly Pavlovich Fokov. Moscow: KNORUS, 2007.P.302.
[22]. Mongush Bolek Sergeevich. Functions of means of protecting civil rights//cyberleninka.ru›article…sredstv…grazhdanskih-prav (date of access: 27. 09. 21).
[23]. Eshchenko Irina Anatolyevna. Civil liability for breach of obligations // Russian judge. 2008. No.5.P. 48
[24]. Guev Alexey Nikolaevich. Civil law: a textbook in 3 volumes. Moscow: INFRA-M., 2003. Vol.1. P.7.
[25]. Egorov Nikolai Dmitrievich. Civil liability // Civil law: a textbook in 3 volumes / otv. ed. Alexander Petrovich Sergeev, Yuri Kirillovich Tolstoy. Moscow.: Prospekt, 2004. Pp. 645, 646.
[26]. Sergeev Alexander Petrovich. Protection of civil rights // Civil law: a textbook in 3 volumes./ed. Alexander Petrovich Sergeev. Moscow: Prospekt, 2012.Vol.1. Pp. 546-547.
[27]. Karkhalev Denis Nikolaevich. Correlation of measures of protection and measures of responsibility in the civil law of Russia: thesis .... cand. legal Sciences Yekaterinburg: Ur. state legal acad., 2003.P.8.
[28]. Kravchenko Alexander Alexandrovich. The ratio of protection measures and liability measures as ways to protect subjective civil rights // Russian Legal Journal. 2015. No. 2. Pp. 3-4, 5.
[29]. Andrey Alexandrovich Kondrashev. Constitutional and legal responsibility and other measures in the mechanism of protection of the constitutional system (measures of protection, control and supervision) // Scientific Yearbook of the Institute of Philosophy and Law of the Ural Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences. 2010.Issue. 10. P.399