Procedural Legal Responsibility: A New Reading
Main Article Content
Abstract
Paying attention to various options for understanding legal liability, the position in which legal liability is interpreted as the application of measures of state coercion is recognized as more preferable. Among its features, special attention is paid to such a feature, according to which it entails negative consequences, the imposition of new additional obligations on offenders. This feature should be especially taken into account when differentiating measures of legal (criminal procedural) liability and protective measures (restorative criminal procedural measures). Procedural legal liability is considered as a complex (integrated) legal institution consisting of norms of both branches of procedural and substantive law. In turn, criminal procedural liability, using specific legal norms as an example, is analyzed as a sub-institute of procedural liability. The purpose of this study was to form the author's understanding of criminal procedural liability. The hypothesis is the statement of the fact that in most cases procedural liability is unreasonably understood as one of the types of legal liability
Article Details
How to Cite
Kozhevnikov, V. V., & Muhammad Ridwan. (2025). Procedural Legal Responsibility: A New Reading. Polit Journal Scientific Journal of Politics, 5(3), 191-201. https://doi.org/10.33258/polit.v5i3.1341
Section
Articles
References
Baitin Mikhail Iosifovich. The Essence of Law (Modern Normative Legal Understanding on the Verge of Two Centuries): Monograph. Moscow: Law and State, 2005. P.227.
Bazylev Boris Timofeevich. Legal liability (theoretical issues). Krasnoyarsk: Krasnoyarsk University, 1985. P. 70.
Bobrova Natalya Alekseevna, Zrazhevskaya Tatyana Dmitrievna. Responsibility in the System of Guarantees of Constitutional Norms (State-Legal Aspects) / scientific. head. Viktor Stepanovich Osnovin. Voronezh: Voronezh University, 1985. P. 115.
Bratus Sergey Nikitich. Legal responsibility and legality. Moscow: Legal lit., 1976. P. 4.
Chashchin Alexander Nikolaevich. Theory of State and Law: textbook. Moscow: Delo i Servis, 2008. P. 363.
Chuklova Elena Valerievna. Concept, grounds and types of procedural liability: general theoretical aspect: diss. Cand. Sci. (Law), Krasnodar: Kuban Agrarian State University, 2009. P. 12.
Commentary on Art. 135 Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation//proupkrf.ru/st_135_upk_rf (Accessed: 29.08. 2023).
Federal Law No. 403-FZ of 28. 12. 2010 "On the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation"// Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation. 2011. No. 1. Article 15.
Gushchin Vasily Vasilyevich. Legal Nature of Penal Procedural Liability // Administrative Law and Process. 2016. No. 5. Pp. 63-66.
Ignatenko Viktor Vasilievich. Legal Responsibility of Election Participants: textbook. settlement Irkutsk: Electoral Commission of the Irkutsk Region, 2006. P. 4.
Ioffe Olimpiad Solomonovich. Law of Obligations. Moscow: Juridical Lit., 1975. P.95.
Khachaturov Rudolf Levonovich, Yagutyan Radik Gaikovich. Legal Liability: A Monograph. Tolyatti: International Academy of Business and Banking, 1995. P. 69.
Kondratieva Svetlana Leonidovna. Legal Liability: the Relationship between Substantive and Procedural Law: Abstract of Cand. Sci. (Law). Moscow: Legal Institute of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 1998. Pp. 4-5.
Korobov Alexander Evgenievich. Legal liability in the sphere of social labor: problems of theory: author's abstract. diss. candidate of legal sciences. SPb: St. Petersburg University, 2009. Pp. 10.
Kovaleva Elena Leonidovna. Legally significant behavior, offenses, legal liability// Problems of the theory of state and law: textbook/edited by Vladimir Mikhailovich Syrykh. Moscow: Eksmo, 2008. P.468.
Kozhevnikov Vladimir Valentinovich, Karavaev Alexander Fedorovich, Zverev Vadim Olegovich. The status of positive legal responsibility in the conceptual and categorical apparatus of the general theory of law // Psychopedagogy in law enforcement agencies. 2018. No. 3. Pp. 88-94.
Kozhevnikov Vladimir Valentinovich. On the Concept of Procedural Law // Law. Journal of the Higher School of Economics. 2022. Vol. 15. No. 4. Pp. 136-154.
Kozhevnikov Vladimir Valentinovich. Theory of State and Law: textbook in 2 parts. Moscow: Prospect, 2021. Part 2 P. 582.
Krasilnikov Sergey Valerievich. Criminal-procedural liability and its implementation: author's abstract. diss. Cand. Sci. (Law). Moscow: Academy of Management of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, 2019. P. 11.
Krasnov Mikhail Alexandrovich. Liability in the system of popular representation. Moscow: Institute of State and Law, 1995. P. 26.
Kuzmin Igor Aleksandrovich. Legal responsibility and its implementation: a tutorial. Irkutsk: Irkutsk State University, 2013. Pp. 15, 17, 18, 140.
Lazarev Valery Mikhailovich, Fedorova Vera Grigoryevna. The principle of legal equality and legal liability (problems of methodology and theory of interrelation): monograph. Volgograd: Volgograd State University, 2005. Pp. 51-52.
Leist Oleg Ernestovich. Main Types of Legal Liability. L.: Leningrad University, 1997. No 3.P.32.
Leist Oleg Ernestovich. Methodological problems of legal liability // Problems of the theory of state and law: textbook / edited by Mikhail Nikolaevich Marchenko. Moscow: Jurist, 2002. P. 634.
Lipinsky Dmitry Anatolyevich, Khachaturov Rudolf Levonovich. General theory of legal liability: monograph. SPb: Legal center Press, 2007. P. 178.
Lipinsky Dmitry Anatolyevich, Musatkina Alexandra Anatolyevna. Legal Liability, Sanctions and Protective Measures: monograph. Moscow: INFRA-M, 2013. Pp.53, 54
Lipinsky Dmitry Anatolyevich. Problems of legal liability: monograph/edited by Rudolf Levonovich Khachaturov. SPb: Legal center Press, 2004. Pp. 58.
Luk'yanova Elena Gennadyevna. Theory of Procedural Law. Moscow: Norma, 2003. P. 223.
Makareiko Nikolay Vladimirovich. Procedural Liability as a Legal Phenomenon // Actual Problems of Economics and Law. 2015. No3. Pp.239, 240, 242, 259.
Makuev Ruman Kharonovich. Theory of State and Law: A Textbook. Moscow: Norma-INFRA-M, 2010. P. 589.
Matuzov Nikolay Ignatyevich, Malko Alexander Vasilyevich. Theory of state and law: textbook. Moscow: Delo, 2009. P. 455.
Melikhov Vadim Aleksandrovich. Procedural liability as a special form of state coercion: theoretical and legal analysis: author's abstract. dis. candidate of legal sciences. Saratov: Saratov State Academy of Law, 2010. P.7.
Ovsepyan Zhanna Iosifovna. Legal responsibility and state coercion (general theoretical and constitutional-legal study). Rostov n / D: Everest, 2005. P. 24.
Pavlushina Alla Aleksandrovna. Theory of legal process: results, problems, development prospects: monograph / edited by Vladimir Mikhailovich Vedyakhin. Samara: Samara State University of Economics, 2005. P. 397.
Petrukhin Igor Leonidovich. Criminal-procedural liability // Jurisprudence. 1984. No. 3. Pp. 61-68.
Pianov Nikolay Andreevich. Consultations on the theory of state and law: textbook. Irkutsk: Irkutsk State University, 2010. P. 497.
Protasov Valery Nikolaevich, Protasova Natalia Valerievna. Lectures on the general theory of law and the theory of state. Moscow: Gorodets, 2010. Pp. 204, 417-418.
Radko Timofey Nikolaevich, Lazarev Valery Vasilyevich, Morozova Lyudmila Aleksandrovna. Theory of state and law: textbook. Moscow: Prospect, 2012. Pp. 365, 382-386.
Rasskazov Leonid Pavlovich. Theory of state and law: textbook. Moscow: RIOR, 2008. Pp.428-429.
Romanov Roman Mikhailovich. Legal liability// Theory of state and law: textbook/ edited by Orest Vladimirovich Martyshin. Moscow: Norma, 2007. P. 406.
Roshchin Mikhail Evgenievich. On the Concept of Civil Liability//Modern Science: Theory and Practice. 2015.No 1. Pp.27-28.
Rumyantsev Oleg Germanovich, Dodonov Vyacheslav Nikolaevich. Encyclopedic legal dictionary. Moscow: INFRA-M, 1997. P.355.
Rybakov Vladimir Alekseevich. Problems of the Theory of State and Law: lecture course. Omsk: Omsk State University named after Fyodor Mikhailovich Dostoevsky, 2010. P.613.
Rybakov Vyacheslav Aleksandrovich. Positive legal responsibility (educational aspects): lecture. Ryazan: Ryazan Higher School of the USSR Ministry of Internal Affairs, 1998. P. 12.
Samoschenko Ivan Sergeevich, Farukshin Mibhat Habibovich. Responsibility under Soviet legislation. Moscow: Legal. Liter., 1971.P.187.
Samoshchenko Ivan Sergeevich. Offenses and Legal Liability: A Textbook. Moscow, 1966. P. 19.
Senyakin Ivan Nikolaevich. Concept, features and types of legal liability//Theory of state and law: course of lectures/edited by Nikolai Ignatyevich Matuzov and Alexander Vasilyevich Malko. Moscow: Jurist, 2007. P. 599.
Serkov Petr Pavlovich. Administrative responsibility in Russian law: modern understanding and new approaches: monograph. Moscow: Norma: INFRA-M, 2012.P.421.
Shargorodsky Mikhail Davidovich. Determinism and responsibility//Jurisprudence. 1968. No. 1. P. 46.
Skachkova Olga Sergeevna. Procedural liability: concept and content: author's abstract. Cand. Sci. (Law). Tambov: Tambov State University named after Gavriil Romanovich Derzhavin. 2007. P. 8.
Smirnov Nikolay Nailevich. On the Retrospective and Positive Aspects of Legal Liability in Law// Law and Process in the 20th Century: Continental Experience and Prospects: Collection of Scientific Articles/ed. Tatyana Vladimirovna Sakhnova. Krasnoyarsk: Siberian Federal University, 2011. Pp. 31-36
Sorokin Vitaly Viktorovich. Theory of legal liability: textbook. Barnaul: Altai State University, 2017. Pp. 26, 33
Terekhin Viktor Aleksandrovich. Legal liability//Theory of state and law: textbook/ edited by Alexander Vasilievich Malko and Alexey Yuryevich. Salomatin. Moscow: Jurid Center Press, 2007. P. 316.
Theory of legal process: monograph / edited by Viktor Mikhailovich Gorshenev. Kharkov: Higher school: Publishing house of Kharkov University, 1985. P. 112.
Theory of state and law: textbook / edited by Albert Semenovich Pigolkin, Yuri Albertovich Dmitriev. Moscow: Higher education, 2009. P. 568.
Ustimenko Yulia Yuryevna. The concept and features of civil liability // Problems of modern science and education. 2015. No. 7. Pp.135-140.
Vasiliev Maxim Vladimirovich, Shurygina Yulia Valerievna. Peculiarities of legal regulation of work of investigators of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation (on the example of the Investigative Department of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation for the Republic of Tatarstan)//Bulletin of Economics, Law and Sociology. 2015. No. 4. P.176.
Vinichenko Oleg Yuryevich, Popov Vladimir Ivanovich. Theory of State and Law: textbook. Moscow: Prospect, 2010. Pp.344, 348-349
Vitchenko Alexander Mikhailovich. Method of legal regulation of socialist public relations. Saratov: Saratov University, 1974. P. 132.
Vitruk Nikolay Vasilyevich. General Theory of Legal Liability: monograph. Moscow: Russian Academy of Justice, 2008. P.93.
Bazylev Boris Timofeevich. Legal liability (theoretical issues). Krasnoyarsk: Krasnoyarsk University, 1985. P. 70.
Bobrova Natalya Alekseevna, Zrazhevskaya Tatyana Dmitrievna. Responsibility in the System of Guarantees of Constitutional Norms (State-Legal Aspects) / scientific. head. Viktor Stepanovich Osnovin. Voronezh: Voronezh University, 1985. P. 115.
Bratus Sergey Nikitich. Legal responsibility and legality. Moscow: Legal lit., 1976. P. 4.
Chashchin Alexander Nikolaevich. Theory of State and Law: textbook. Moscow: Delo i Servis, 2008. P. 363.
Chuklova Elena Valerievna. Concept, grounds and types of procedural liability: general theoretical aspect: diss. Cand. Sci. (Law), Krasnodar: Kuban Agrarian State University, 2009. P. 12.
Commentary on Art. 135 Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation//proupkrf.ru/st_135_upk_rf (Accessed: 29.08. 2023).
Federal Law No. 403-FZ of 28. 12. 2010 "On the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation"// Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation. 2011. No. 1. Article 15.
Gushchin Vasily Vasilyevich. Legal Nature of Penal Procedural Liability // Administrative Law and Process. 2016. No. 5. Pp. 63-66.
Ignatenko Viktor Vasilievich. Legal Responsibility of Election Participants: textbook. settlement Irkutsk: Electoral Commission of the Irkutsk Region, 2006. P. 4.
Ioffe Olimpiad Solomonovich. Law of Obligations. Moscow: Juridical Lit., 1975. P.95.
Khachaturov Rudolf Levonovich, Yagutyan Radik Gaikovich. Legal Liability: A Monograph. Tolyatti: International Academy of Business and Banking, 1995. P. 69.
Kondratieva Svetlana Leonidovna. Legal Liability: the Relationship between Substantive and Procedural Law: Abstract of Cand. Sci. (Law). Moscow: Legal Institute of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 1998. Pp. 4-5.
Korobov Alexander Evgenievich. Legal liability in the sphere of social labor: problems of theory: author's abstract. diss. candidate of legal sciences. SPb: St. Petersburg University, 2009. Pp. 10.
Kovaleva Elena Leonidovna. Legally significant behavior, offenses, legal liability// Problems of the theory of state and law: textbook/edited by Vladimir Mikhailovich Syrykh. Moscow: Eksmo, 2008. P.468.
Kozhevnikov Vladimir Valentinovich, Karavaev Alexander Fedorovich, Zverev Vadim Olegovich. The status of positive legal responsibility in the conceptual and categorical apparatus of the general theory of law // Psychopedagogy in law enforcement agencies. 2018. No. 3. Pp. 88-94.
Kozhevnikov Vladimir Valentinovich. On the Concept of Procedural Law // Law. Journal of the Higher School of Economics. 2022. Vol. 15. No. 4. Pp. 136-154.
Kozhevnikov Vladimir Valentinovich. Theory of State and Law: textbook in 2 parts. Moscow: Prospect, 2021. Part 2 P. 582.
Krasilnikov Sergey Valerievich. Criminal-procedural liability and its implementation: author's abstract. diss. Cand. Sci. (Law). Moscow: Academy of Management of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, 2019. P. 11.
Krasnov Mikhail Alexandrovich. Liability in the system of popular representation. Moscow: Institute of State and Law, 1995. P. 26.
Kuzmin Igor Aleksandrovich. Legal responsibility and its implementation: a tutorial. Irkutsk: Irkutsk State University, 2013. Pp. 15, 17, 18, 140.
Lazarev Valery Mikhailovich, Fedorova Vera Grigoryevna. The principle of legal equality and legal liability (problems of methodology and theory of interrelation): monograph. Volgograd: Volgograd State University, 2005. Pp. 51-52.
Leist Oleg Ernestovich. Main Types of Legal Liability. L.: Leningrad University, 1997. No 3.P.32.
Leist Oleg Ernestovich. Methodological problems of legal liability // Problems of the theory of state and law: textbook / edited by Mikhail Nikolaevich Marchenko. Moscow: Jurist, 2002. P. 634.
Lipinsky Dmitry Anatolyevich, Khachaturov Rudolf Levonovich. General theory of legal liability: monograph. SPb: Legal center Press, 2007. P. 178.
Lipinsky Dmitry Anatolyevich, Musatkina Alexandra Anatolyevna. Legal Liability, Sanctions and Protective Measures: monograph. Moscow: INFRA-M, 2013. Pp.53, 54
Lipinsky Dmitry Anatolyevich. Problems of legal liability: monograph/edited by Rudolf Levonovich Khachaturov. SPb: Legal center Press, 2004. Pp. 58.
Luk'yanova Elena Gennadyevna. Theory of Procedural Law. Moscow: Norma, 2003. P. 223.
Makareiko Nikolay Vladimirovich. Procedural Liability as a Legal Phenomenon // Actual Problems of Economics and Law. 2015. No3. Pp.239, 240, 242, 259.
Makuev Ruman Kharonovich. Theory of State and Law: A Textbook. Moscow: Norma-INFRA-M, 2010. P. 589.
Matuzov Nikolay Ignatyevich, Malko Alexander Vasilyevich. Theory of state and law: textbook. Moscow: Delo, 2009. P. 455.
Melikhov Vadim Aleksandrovich. Procedural liability as a special form of state coercion: theoretical and legal analysis: author's abstract. dis. candidate of legal sciences. Saratov: Saratov State Academy of Law, 2010. P.7.
Ovsepyan Zhanna Iosifovna. Legal responsibility and state coercion (general theoretical and constitutional-legal study). Rostov n / D: Everest, 2005. P. 24.
Pavlushina Alla Aleksandrovna. Theory of legal process: results, problems, development prospects: monograph / edited by Vladimir Mikhailovich Vedyakhin. Samara: Samara State University of Economics, 2005. P. 397.
Petrukhin Igor Leonidovich. Criminal-procedural liability // Jurisprudence. 1984. No. 3. Pp. 61-68.
Pianov Nikolay Andreevich. Consultations on the theory of state and law: textbook. Irkutsk: Irkutsk State University, 2010. P. 497.
Protasov Valery Nikolaevich, Protasova Natalia Valerievna. Lectures on the general theory of law and the theory of state. Moscow: Gorodets, 2010. Pp. 204, 417-418.
Radko Timofey Nikolaevich, Lazarev Valery Vasilyevich, Morozova Lyudmila Aleksandrovna. Theory of state and law: textbook. Moscow: Prospect, 2012. Pp. 365, 382-386.
Rasskazov Leonid Pavlovich. Theory of state and law: textbook. Moscow: RIOR, 2008. Pp.428-429.
Romanov Roman Mikhailovich. Legal liability// Theory of state and law: textbook/ edited by Orest Vladimirovich Martyshin. Moscow: Norma, 2007. P. 406.
Roshchin Mikhail Evgenievich. On the Concept of Civil Liability//Modern Science: Theory and Practice. 2015.No 1. Pp.27-28.
Rumyantsev Oleg Germanovich, Dodonov Vyacheslav Nikolaevich. Encyclopedic legal dictionary. Moscow: INFRA-M, 1997. P.355.
Rybakov Vladimir Alekseevich. Problems of the Theory of State and Law: lecture course. Omsk: Omsk State University named after Fyodor Mikhailovich Dostoevsky, 2010. P.613.
Rybakov Vyacheslav Aleksandrovich. Positive legal responsibility (educational aspects): lecture. Ryazan: Ryazan Higher School of the USSR Ministry of Internal Affairs, 1998. P. 12.
Samoschenko Ivan Sergeevich, Farukshin Mibhat Habibovich. Responsibility under Soviet legislation. Moscow: Legal. Liter., 1971.P.187.
Samoshchenko Ivan Sergeevich. Offenses and Legal Liability: A Textbook. Moscow, 1966. P. 19.
Senyakin Ivan Nikolaevich. Concept, features and types of legal liability//Theory of state and law: course of lectures/edited by Nikolai Ignatyevich Matuzov and Alexander Vasilyevich Malko. Moscow: Jurist, 2007. P. 599.
Serkov Petr Pavlovich. Administrative responsibility in Russian law: modern understanding and new approaches: monograph. Moscow: Norma: INFRA-M, 2012.P.421.
Shargorodsky Mikhail Davidovich. Determinism and responsibility//Jurisprudence. 1968. No. 1. P. 46.
Skachkova Olga Sergeevna. Procedural liability: concept and content: author's abstract. Cand. Sci. (Law). Tambov: Tambov State University named after Gavriil Romanovich Derzhavin. 2007. P. 8.
Smirnov Nikolay Nailevich. On the Retrospective and Positive Aspects of Legal Liability in Law// Law and Process in the 20th Century: Continental Experience and Prospects: Collection of Scientific Articles/ed. Tatyana Vladimirovna Sakhnova. Krasnoyarsk: Siberian Federal University, 2011. Pp. 31-36
Sorokin Vitaly Viktorovich. Theory of legal liability: textbook. Barnaul: Altai State University, 2017. Pp. 26, 33
Terekhin Viktor Aleksandrovich. Legal liability//Theory of state and law: textbook/ edited by Alexander Vasilievich Malko and Alexey Yuryevich. Salomatin. Moscow: Jurid Center Press, 2007. P. 316.
Theory of legal process: monograph / edited by Viktor Mikhailovich Gorshenev. Kharkov: Higher school: Publishing house of Kharkov University, 1985. P. 112.
Theory of state and law: textbook / edited by Albert Semenovich Pigolkin, Yuri Albertovich Dmitriev. Moscow: Higher education, 2009. P. 568.
Ustimenko Yulia Yuryevna. The concept and features of civil liability // Problems of modern science and education. 2015. No. 7. Pp.135-140.
Vasiliev Maxim Vladimirovich, Shurygina Yulia Valerievna. Peculiarities of legal regulation of work of investigators of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation (on the example of the Investigative Department of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation for the Republic of Tatarstan)//Bulletin of Economics, Law and Sociology. 2015. No. 4. P.176.
Vinichenko Oleg Yuryevich, Popov Vladimir Ivanovich. Theory of State and Law: textbook. Moscow: Prospect, 2010. Pp.344, 348-349
Vitchenko Alexander Mikhailovich. Method of legal regulation of socialist public relations. Saratov: Saratov University, 1974. P. 132.
Vitruk Nikolay Vasilyevich. General Theory of Legal Liability: monograph. Moscow: Russian Academy of Justice, 2008. P.93.