Doctrinal (Conceptual) Errors: General Theoretical Aspect
Main Article Content
Abstract
This scientific article examines the problem of the relationship between doctrinal (conceptual) and law-making legal errors. The concept of legal error is considered and its symptoms are analyzed. Attention is paid to the characteristics of doctrinal errors, their characteristics, among which the most important is their political and ideological nature. Analysis of the legal literature made it possible to identify two approaches to solving the problem posed. Proponents of the first approach, both representatives of the general theory of law and branch sciences, believe that doctrinal errors are types of law-making errors. Being embodied in a normative legal act, they are also law-making errors. The author supports the more substantiated position of supporters of the second approach, who, distinguishing between doctrinal and law-making errors, believe that the first can arise at the stage of the process of cognition of objective laws that lie outside the law-making process; that doctrinal errors are a prerequisite for law-making errors. In conclusion, attention is drawn to the important role of legal science in preventing doctrinal errors.
Article Details
How to Cite
Kozhevnikov, V. V. (2025). Doctrinal (Conceptual) Errors: General Theoretical Aspect. Polit Journal Scientific Journal of Politics, 5(1), 57-66. https://doi.org/10.33258/polit.v5i1.1268
Section
Articles
References
Andryushchenko Evgeny Grigorievich. What doctrine is necessary for Russian education//Law and education. 2002. No. 2. P. 15.
Baranov Vladimir Mikhailovich, Pshenichnov Mikhail Aleksandrovich. Law-making errors as a factor of disharmony in legal development (based on the materials of the International scientific and practical scientific round table "Law-making errors: concept, types, practice and technique of elimination in post-Soviet states" (Nizhny Novgorod. May 29-30, 2008) (end of review) // Legal technique. 2009. No. 3. P. 568.
Baranov Vladimir Mikhailovich, Pshenichnov Mikhail Alexandrovich. Law-making errors as a factor of disharmony in legal development (based on the materials of the International scientific and practical round table "Law-making errors: concept, types, practice and technique of elimination in post-Soviet states". Nizhny Novgorod: Nizhny Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, May 29-30, 2008 // Legal technique. 2008. No. 2. Pp. 176, 177-178.
Big soviet encyclopedia in 30 volumes / edited by Alexander Mikhailovich Prokhorov. Moscow: Soviet Encyclopedia, 1972. Vol. 7. P. 403.
Borisov Alexander Sergeevich, Merkulov Pavel Alexandrovich. Some problems of modern lawmaking in Russia // Society and power. 2015. No. 3. P. 67.
Dal Vladimir Ivanovich. Explanatory Dictionary of the Living Great Russian Language in 4 Volumes. Moscow: Russkiy Yazyk, 1981. Vol. 2. P. 633.
Davydova Marina Leonidovna. Explicit and implicit errors of the legislator: problems of classification and legal consequences // Lawmaking errors: concept, types, practice and technique of elimination in post-Soviet states: materials of the International scientific and practical round table / edited by Vladimir Mikhailovich Baranov and Igor Mikhailovich Mitskevich. Moscow: Prospect, 2009. Pp. 318-319.
Decree of the President of 05.12. 2016 No. 646 "On approval of the Doctrine of information security of the Russian Federation" // Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation. 2016. No. 50. Art. 7074.
Decree of the President of the Russian Federation of 13. 06. 1996 No. 884 "On the doctrine of the development of Russian science" // Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation. 1996. No. 25. Art. 3005.
Derkho Daniil Sergeevich. General Approaches to Defining and Structuring the Guiding Principles of Constitutional Lawmaking // Approbation. 2015. No. 3. P. 91.
Getmanova Alexandra Denisovna. Logic for lawyers: a textbook. Moscow: KNORUS, 2006. P. 4.
Kartashov Vladimir Nikolaevich, Toropov Andrey Anatolyevich. The Concept of Error in Professional Legal Activity // Current Issues of Jurisprudence: Collection of Abstracts of Students, Postgraduates, and Applicants. Yaroslavl: Pavel Grigorievich Demidov Yaroslavl State University, 1997. P. 11.
Kartashov Vladimir Nikolaevich, Vanteeva Natalia Vladimirovna. Erroneous legal activity of local governments (some methodological, theoretical and practical-applied aspects of the problem). Yaroslavl: Yaroslavl State University named after Pavel Grigorievich Demidov, 2010. Pp.14-15.
Kartashov Vladimir Nikolaevich. The Theory of the Legal System of Society in 2 Volumes. Yaroslavl: Yaroslavl State University, 2006. Vol.2. Pp.144-154.
Kaufman Mikhail Aleksandrovich. Law-making errors in criminal law // Journal of Russian law. 2016.№9. Pp.92-94.
Khalmetov Ali Izmailovich. The Concept of Doctrine and Doctrinal Sources in Russian Law // Electronic Scientific Journal “Science. Society. State”. 2020. No. 3 (31). P. 116
Kolyev Andrey Nikolaevich. Nation and state. Theory of conservative reconstruction. Moscow: Logos, 2005.Pp.108-109.
Korobova Alexandra Petrovna. Priorities of legal policy // Russian legal policy / edited by Nikolai Ignatyevich Matuzov, Alexander Vasilyevich Malko. Moscow: Norma, 2003. P. 106.
Krasnova Tatyana Vladimirovna. Deprivation of parental rights: conceptual errors of the legislator and problems of law enforcement practice // Bulletin of Omsk University. Law. 2013. No. 3. P. 143.
Kulapov Viktor Lavrenevich. Theoretical foundations of the state and law. Saratov: Saratov State Academy of Law, 2003. P. 110.
Lashkov Alexander Sergeevich. Law-making errors. Problems of theory and practice: author's abstract. diss... candidate of legal sciences. St. Petersburg, 1999. P. 11.
Latynin Oleg Anatolyevich. Doctrine and theory: similarities and differences // History of the state and law. 2019. No. 3. Pp. 16-17.
Latynin Oleg Anatolyevich. On the issue of defining the concept of legal doctrine and the relationship of legal doctrine with close concepts // Scientific notes of the Crimean Federal University named after Vladimir Ivanovich Vernadsky. Legal sciences. 2019. Vol. 5 (71). No. 4. P. 47.
Legal Encyclopedia / edited by Lyudmila Vasilievna Tikhomirova, Mikhail Yuryevich Tikhomirov. Moscow: Yurinformcenter, 1997. P. 293.
Lisyutkin Alexander Borisovich. Questions of methodology of the study of "errors" in jurisprudence / edited by Nikolai Ignatyevich Matuzov. Saratov, 2001. P. 129.
Lyubetenko Dmitry Yuryevich. On the issue of classification of legal doctrines // Bulletin of Perm University. Legal sciences. 2010. Issue. 4 (10). P. 24. Pp. 22-26.
Madaev Evgeny Olegovich. Doctrines in the legal system of the Russian Federation: author's abstract. diss. legal. sciences. Moscow: Higher School of Economics, 2012. Pp. 61-62.
Maltsev Gennady Vasilyevich. Ideology, politics and law (some issues of their relationship) // Soviet state and law. 1970. No 2. P. 19.
Military doctrine of the Russian Federation, approved. by the President of the Russian Federation on 25. 12. 2014 No. Pr-2976 // Rossiyskaya Gazeta. 2014. No. 298.
Morozova Lyudmila Aleksandrovna. Law-making errors and procedural means of their elimination // State and Law. 2010. No 1. P. 10.
Nersesyants Vladik Sumbatovich. General theory of law and state: textbook. Moscow: Norma, 1999. P. 382.
Ozhegov Sergey Ivanovich. Dictionary of the Russian language. Moscow: Russian language, 1984. Pp. 148, 419.
Philosophical Dictionary / edited by Mark Moiseevich Rosenthal. Moscow: Politizdat, 19975. P. 306.
Pryakhina Tatyana Mikhailovna. Constitutional doctrine of the Russian Federation / scientific. ed. Viktor Osipovich Luchin. Moscow: UNITY, Law and Right, 2006. P. 13.
Puzikov Ruslan Vladimirovich. Legal Doctrine in the Sphere of Legal Regulation: diss…. candidate of legal sciences. Nizhny Novgorod: Nizhny Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, 2003. Pp. 177-178.
Radko Timofey Nikolaevich, Lazarev Valery Vasilyevich, Morozova Lyudmila Aleksandrovna. Theory of State and Law: textbook. Moscow: Prospect, 2012. Pp. 230-232, 235-236.
Rumyantsev Mikhail Borisovich. Law Education and Lawmaking in the Russian Federation: monograph. Cheboksary: Sreda, 2019. P.266.
Russian Legislation: Problems and Prospects / ed. Yuri Petrovich Orlovsky, Yuri Aleksandrovich Tikhomirov. Moscow: BEK, 1995. Pp. 383-384.
Sociological Encyclopedic Dictionary / edited by Gennady Vasilyevich Osipov. // https://libcats.org/book/633128 (accessed: 02/26/2024).
Syrykh Vladimir Mikhailovich, Baranov Vladimir Mikhailovich. Legislative errors: concept and typology // Legislative technique of modern Russia: state, problems, improvement in 2 volumes / edited by Vladimir Mikhailovich Baranov. Nizhny Novgorod: Nizhny Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, 2001. Vol.1. P.387.
Tikhomirov Yuri Alexandrovich. Legal design: criteria and errors // Journal of Russian law. 2008. No 2. P.5-6.
Tumanov Vladimir Aleksandrovich. Ideological aspects of the legal system // Legal system of socialism in 2 books / edited by Andrey Mikhailovich Vasiliev. Moscow: Legal Literature, 1986. Book 1. Concept, structure, social connections. P.177.
Vasiliev Anton Alexandrovich. Legal doctrine as a source of law (historical and theoretical issues): author's abstract. diss. candidate of legal sciences. Krasnoyarsk: Siberian Federal University, 2007. P. 15.
Voplenko Nikolay Nikolaevich. Errors in lawmaking: concept and types // Essays on Russian legislation / edited by Ivan Nikolaevich Senyakin. Volgograd: Volgograd scientific publishing house, 2010. Part 2. P. 181.
Baranov Vladimir Mikhailovich, Pshenichnov Mikhail Aleksandrovich. Law-making errors as a factor of disharmony in legal development (based on the materials of the International scientific and practical scientific round table "Law-making errors: concept, types, practice and technique of elimination in post-Soviet states" (Nizhny Novgorod. May 29-30, 2008) (end of review) // Legal technique. 2009. No. 3. P. 568.
Baranov Vladimir Mikhailovich, Pshenichnov Mikhail Alexandrovich. Law-making errors as a factor of disharmony in legal development (based on the materials of the International scientific and practical round table "Law-making errors: concept, types, practice and technique of elimination in post-Soviet states". Nizhny Novgorod: Nizhny Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, May 29-30, 2008 // Legal technique. 2008. No. 2. Pp. 176, 177-178.
Big soviet encyclopedia in 30 volumes / edited by Alexander Mikhailovich Prokhorov. Moscow: Soviet Encyclopedia, 1972. Vol. 7. P. 403.
Borisov Alexander Sergeevich, Merkulov Pavel Alexandrovich. Some problems of modern lawmaking in Russia // Society and power. 2015. No. 3. P. 67.
Dal Vladimir Ivanovich. Explanatory Dictionary of the Living Great Russian Language in 4 Volumes. Moscow: Russkiy Yazyk, 1981. Vol. 2. P. 633.
Davydova Marina Leonidovna. Explicit and implicit errors of the legislator: problems of classification and legal consequences // Lawmaking errors: concept, types, practice and technique of elimination in post-Soviet states: materials of the International scientific and practical round table / edited by Vladimir Mikhailovich Baranov and Igor Mikhailovich Mitskevich. Moscow: Prospect, 2009. Pp. 318-319.
Decree of the President of 05.12. 2016 No. 646 "On approval of the Doctrine of information security of the Russian Federation" // Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation. 2016. No. 50. Art. 7074.
Decree of the President of the Russian Federation of 13. 06. 1996 No. 884 "On the doctrine of the development of Russian science" // Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation. 1996. No. 25. Art. 3005.
Derkho Daniil Sergeevich. General Approaches to Defining and Structuring the Guiding Principles of Constitutional Lawmaking // Approbation. 2015. No. 3. P. 91.
Getmanova Alexandra Denisovna. Logic for lawyers: a textbook. Moscow: KNORUS, 2006. P. 4.
Kartashov Vladimir Nikolaevich, Toropov Andrey Anatolyevich. The Concept of Error in Professional Legal Activity // Current Issues of Jurisprudence: Collection of Abstracts of Students, Postgraduates, and Applicants. Yaroslavl: Pavel Grigorievich Demidov Yaroslavl State University, 1997. P. 11.
Kartashov Vladimir Nikolaevich, Vanteeva Natalia Vladimirovna. Erroneous legal activity of local governments (some methodological, theoretical and practical-applied aspects of the problem). Yaroslavl: Yaroslavl State University named after Pavel Grigorievich Demidov, 2010. Pp.14-15.
Kartashov Vladimir Nikolaevich. The Theory of the Legal System of Society in 2 Volumes. Yaroslavl: Yaroslavl State University, 2006. Vol.2. Pp.144-154.
Kaufman Mikhail Aleksandrovich. Law-making errors in criminal law // Journal of Russian law. 2016.№9. Pp.92-94.
Khalmetov Ali Izmailovich. The Concept of Doctrine and Doctrinal Sources in Russian Law // Electronic Scientific Journal “Science. Society. State”. 2020. No. 3 (31). P. 116
Kolyev Andrey Nikolaevich. Nation and state. Theory of conservative reconstruction. Moscow: Logos, 2005.Pp.108-109.
Korobova Alexandra Petrovna. Priorities of legal policy // Russian legal policy / edited by Nikolai Ignatyevich Matuzov, Alexander Vasilyevich Malko. Moscow: Norma, 2003. P. 106.
Krasnova Tatyana Vladimirovna. Deprivation of parental rights: conceptual errors of the legislator and problems of law enforcement practice // Bulletin of Omsk University. Law. 2013. No. 3. P. 143.
Kulapov Viktor Lavrenevich. Theoretical foundations of the state and law. Saratov: Saratov State Academy of Law, 2003. P. 110.
Lashkov Alexander Sergeevich. Law-making errors. Problems of theory and practice: author's abstract. diss... candidate of legal sciences. St. Petersburg, 1999. P. 11.
Latynin Oleg Anatolyevich. Doctrine and theory: similarities and differences // History of the state and law. 2019. No. 3. Pp. 16-17.
Latynin Oleg Anatolyevich. On the issue of defining the concept of legal doctrine and the relationship of legal doctrine with close concepts // Scientific notes of the Crimean Federal University named after Vladimir Ivanovich Vernadsky. Legal sciences. 2019. Vol. 5 (71). No. 4. P. 47.
Legal Encyclopedia / edited by Lyudmila Vasilievna Tikhomirova, Mikhail Yuryevich Tikhomirov. Moscow: Yurinformcenter, 1997. P. 293.
Lisyutkin Alexander Borisovich. Questions of methodology of the study of "errors" in jurisprudence / edited by Nikolai Ignatyevich Matuzov. Saratov, 2001. P. 129.
Lyubetenko Dmitry Yuryevich. On the issue of classification of legal doctrines // Bulletin of Perm University. Legal sciences. 2010. Issue. 4 (10). P. 24. Pp. 22-26.
Madaev Evgeny Olegovich. Doctrines in the legal system of the Russian Federation: author's abstract. diss. legal. sciences. Moscow: Higher School of Economics, 2012. Pp. 61-62.
Maltsev Gennady Vasilyevich. Ideology, politics and law (some issues of their relationship) // Soviet state and law. 1970. No 2. P. 19.
Military doctrine of the Russian Federation, approved. by the President of the Russian Federation on 25. 12. 2014 No. Pr-2976 // Rossiyskaya Gazeta. 2014. No. 298.
Morozova Lyudmila Aleksandrovna. Law-making errors and procedural means of their elimination // State and Law. 2010. No 1. P. 10.
Nersesyants Vladik Sumbatovich. General theory of law and state: textbook. Moscow: Norma, 1999. P. 382.
Ozhegov Sergey Ivanovich. Dictionary of the Russian language. Moscow: Russian language, 1984. Pp. 148, 419.
Philosophical Dictionary / edited by Mark Moiseevich Rosenthal. Moscow: Politizdat, 19975. P. 306.
Pryakhina Tatyana Mikhailovna. Constitutional doctrine of the Russian Federation / scientific. ed. Viktor Osipovich Luchin. Moscow: UNITY, Law and Right, 2006. P. 13.
Puzikov Ruslan Vladimirovich. Legal Doctrine in the Sphere of Legal Regulation: diss…. candidate of legal sciences. Nizhny Novgorod: Nizhny Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, 2003. Pp. 177-178.
Radko Timofey Nikolaevich, Lazarev Valery Vasilyevich, Morozova Lyudmila Aleksandrovna. Theory of State and Law: textbook. Moscow: Prospect, 2012. Pp. 230-232, 235-236.
Rumyantsev Mikhail Borisovich. Law Education and Lawmaking in the Russian Federation: monograph. Cheboksary: Sreda, 2019. P.266.
Russian Legislation: Problems and Prospects / ed. Yuri Petrovich Orlovsky, Yuri Aleksandrovich Tikhomirov. Moscow: BEK, 1995. Pp. 383-384.
Sociological Encyclopedic Dictionary / edited by Gennady Vasilyevich Osipov. // https://libcats.org/book/633128 (accessed: 02/26/2024).
Syrykh Vladimir Mikhailovich, Baranov Vladimir Mikhailovich. Legislative errors: concept and typology // Legislative technique of modern Russia: state, problems, improvement in 2 volumes / edited by Vladimir Mikhailovich Baranov. Nizhny Novgorod: Nizhny Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, 2001. Vol.1. P.387.
Tikhomirov Yuri Alexandrovich. Legal design: criteria and errors // Journal of Russian law. 2008. No 2. P.5-6.
Tumanov Vladimir Aleksandrovich. Ideological aspects of the legal system // Legal system of socialism in 2 books / edited by Andrey Mikhailovich Vasiliev. Moscow: Legal Literature, 1986. Book 1. Concept, structure, social connections. P.177.
Vasiliev Anton Alexandrovich. Legal doctrine as a source of law (historical and theoretical issues): author's abstract. diss. candidate of legal sciences. Krasnoyarsk: Siberian Federal University, 2007. P. 15.
Voplenko Nikolay Nikolaevich. Errors in lawmaking: concept and types // Essays on Russian legislation / edited by Ivan Nikolaevich Senyakin. Volgograd: Volgograd scientific publishing house, 2010. Part 2. P. 181.